Custom Signature Sugar Cookies
Our Sugar cookies begin with a classic recipe inspired by both sugar and shortbread cookies. Soft, buttery, and perfectly sweet, they have a tender bite that complements our royal icing designs without overpowering them.
Every cookie is created specifically for your celebration—from the colors and theme to the smallest details. Whether you’re looking for something clean and classic or an intricate set filled with hand-piped details, we’ll create something that’s uniquely yours.
Choose Your Level of Detail
Classic
Clean, polished designs with minimal detail for a timeless, classic look.
Detailed
A balanced mix of simple and intricate designs, with detailed piping, lettering, textures, and decorative elements.
Elaborate
Intricate designs featuring advanced techniques, personalization, detailed piping, and elevated finishing touches.
Add a footnote if this applies to your business
Before You Order
Custom cookies are made to order and require advance planning.
To ensure enough time for designing, preparing and decorating your order, we recommend placing your order 3 weeks before your event date.
Need them sooner?
Rush orders may be accomadated based on availibility and will be subject to a rush fee. Please inquire before placing your order.
A few things to know
- Custom cookie pricing is per dozen.
- Each set is uniquely designed for your event, with pricing based on the overall level of detail
- Final designs, colors, wording, and quantities are confirmed during the ordering process.
- A minimum order of one dozen applies.
Gourmet Cookies
Our gourmet cookies are oversized, indulgent, and thoughtfully crafted with premium ingredients. Baked with lightly crisp edges and a soft, tender center, each flavor is carefully balanced with generous mix-ins for a truly elevated bakery-style cookie.
Signature Gourmet Cookie Flavors
Holy Biscoff
Brown Butter Toffee
Holy Biscoff
A rich, buttery cookie loaded with Biscoff pieces and white chocolate, with a smooth, decadent Biscoff center.
Oh My Oreo
Brown Butter Toffee
Holy Biscoff
Loaded with crushed Oreo pieces and white chocolate chips, this cookies-and-cream favorite delivers rich chocolate flavor and plenty of Oreo in every bite.
Brown Butter Toffee
Brown Butter Toffee
Brown Butter Toffee
A rich browned-butter toffee stuffed with a gooey caramel center and finished with a caramel drizzle finished.
Cookie Monster
Stuffed Nutella
Brown Butter Toffee
A vibrant blue cookie featuring crushed Oreos and Chips Ahoy cookies, with white chocolate and chocolate chips throughout.
Funfetti Circus
Stuffed Nutella
Stuffed Nutella
A festive funfetti cake-flavored cookie with colorful sprinkles, Circus Animal Cookies, and creamy white chocolate chips for a nostalgic, celebratory treat.
Stuffed Nutella
Stuffed Nutella
Stuffed Nutella
A rich hazelnut cookie with dark chocolate and a creamy Nutella center for an indulgent combination of chocolate and hazelnut.
Campfire
Raspberry Lemon
Raspberry Lemon
A classic s’mores-inspired cookie with a graham cracker crust, chocolate chips, and Hershey’s chocolate, finished with a fluffy marshmallow center.
Raspberry Lemon
Raspberry Lemon
Raspberry Lemon
A bright, refreshing combination of zesty lemon and sweet raspberry, paired with creamy white chocolate chips and finished with a smooth lemon icing.
Blackout
Raspberry Lemon
The Classic
A chocolate lover’s dream—an intensely rich, fudgy chocolate cookie with deep cocoa flavor, finished with a decadent dark chocolate drizzle.
The Classic
The Classic
The Classic
A timeless bakery-style chocolate chip cookie with a soft, tender center, lightly crisp edges, and plenty of rich chocolate chips.
Magic 7
The Classic
Rocky Road
A deliciously sweet combination of butterscotch, white chocolate, chocolate chips, and coconut, all nestled over a rich graham cracker crust.
Rocky Road
The Classic
Rocky Road
A rich, indulgent chocolate cookie with crunchy almonds, chocolate chips, and a fluffy marshmallow center for a decadent twist on the classic Rocky Road combination.
Signature Gourmet Cookie Flavors continued
PB Bomb
The Ultimate Brookie
A rich, buttery cookie loaded with Biscoff pieces and white chocolate, with a smooth, decadent Biscoff center.
The Ultimate Brookie
The Ultimate Brookie
The ultimate chocolate indulgence—a rich cookie packed with brownie chunks and chocolate chips, finished with a decadent gooey brownie center.
New Flavor
New Flavor
New Flavor
In Progress
Specialty Sweets
Cake Pops
Cake Shooters
Cake Pops
Bite-sized cake treats dipped in chocolate and finished with a simple drizzle and sprinkle detail.
Classic — $42/dozen
Custom — $48–$54/dozen
Detailed Custom — $60+/dozen
Cupcakes
Cake Shooters
Cake Pops
Classic bakery-style cupcakes with a soft, tender crumb and creamy frosting.
Starting at $48/dozen
Cake Shooters
Cake Shooters
Rice Krispy Treats
Individual layered desserts featuring moist cake, creamy filling, and frosting in every bite.
Starting at $54/dozen
Rice Krispy Treats
Chocolate Dipped Pretzels
Rice Krispy Treats
Crispy, chewy Rice Krispie treats dipped in chocolate and finished with a simple drizzle and sprinkle detail.
Classic — $36/dozen
Custom — $42–$48/dozen
Detailed Custom — $54+/dozen
Chocolate Covered Oreos
Chocolate Dipped Pretzels
Chocolate Dipped Pretzels
Classic Oreo cookies dipped in chocolate and finished with a simple drizzle and sprinkle detail..
Starting at $42/dozen
Chocolate Dipped Pretzels
Chocolate Dipped Pretzels
Chocolate Dipped Pretzels
Chocolate-dipped pretzels finished with a simple drizzle and sprinkle detail.
Choose from two classic styles:
Old-Fashioned Pretzels
Pretzel Rods
Starting at $36/dozen